Supreme Court to Evaluate Critical Habitat Limits as Services Ramp up ESA Reform Efforts
On April 2, 2018, the Services sent over a package of proposed ESA regulations to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) that would likely result in significant changes for the ESA program and could streamline certain ESA-related federal permitting requirements. The three proposals are as follows:
At the same time as these ESA reforms are under consideration by the White House, the Supreme Court is set to review the extent of the Services’ authority to designate critical habitat in Weyerhaeuser Co. v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, a timber company’s challenge to the FWS designation of approximately 1,500 acres of private land in Louisiana as critical habitat for the endangered dusky gopher frog. A divided panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit upheld FWS’s designation, even though the land at issue is unoccupied by the frog, cannot be occupied by the frog unless the land is significantly altered for the frog’s benefit, and does not play any supporting role in sustaining the frog or its habitat.
The case, which is set for oral argument on October 1, 2018, will be the first case the Justices hear upon return from their summer recess and, if Judge Brett Kavanaugh is confirmed by then, it could be his first case on the bench. It will be the first ESA case decided by the Supreme Court in more than a decade.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in the Weyerhaeuser case could provide some key guidance on the circumstances under which the Services can designate as critical habitat areas that are not actually occupied by the listed species. It will also likely address whether a decision by the Services not to exclude an area from a critical habitat designation because of the economic impact is subject to judicial review. Accordingly, this ruling could set some key limits that will inform and could potentially alter the Services’ proposal to amend the critical habitat designation criteria.
Link to article
- New Regulation on The Types of Planned Businesses and/or Activities which Require an Environmental Impact Assessment
- EPA Walks Back 2017 Risk Management Program Amendments Applicable to Stationary Sources
- Applying for a Business License in 2020? You May Need to Consider Your Water Quality Impacts
- New Regulation on Location Permit
WSG Member: Please login to add your comment.